diff --git a/ICD.Common.Utils/Collections/PriorityQueue.cs b/ICD.Common.Utils/Collections/PriorityQueue.cs
index e66ddfe..7ec5e14 100644
--- a/ICD.Common.Utils/Collections/PriorityQueue.cs
+++ b/ICD.Common.Utils/Collections/PriorityQueue.cs
@@ -148,7 +148,11 @@ namespace ICD.Common.Utils.Collections
 				if (!inserted)
 				{
 					int insertIndex = removeIndices[0];
-					kvp.Value.Insert(insertIndex, item);
+
+					if (insertIndex >= kvp.Value.Count)
+						kvp.Value.Add(item);
+					else
+						kvp.Value.Insert(insertIndex, item);
 					m_Count++;
 
 					inserted = true;